Through the use of clinical examples, the paper demonstrates how couples use projective identification mechanisms to collude in maintaining the belief that the survivor is the identified patient in the couple system. Finally, on the basis of the understanding of projective identification arrived at earlier in the paper, there is a discussion of the resulting implications for psychotherapeutic technique and for clinical theory. The event took place on 12 june 2012 at the institute of psychoanalysis, london. Projection projection is a defense mechanism that typically involves three steps. Padagogische psychologie german edition pdf free download. Understanding projective identification louise braddock. Projective identification and projection are defined, described, and contrasted. This paper is devoted to the logic of the unconscious and its application to the analysis of projective intentionality in psychoanalysis. This paper considers whether the psychoanalytic concept of projective identification might supplement or enrich.
Intersubjectivity projective identification and otherness. Unlimited viewing of the articlechapter pdf and any associated supplements and figures. The concept of projective identification projection, identification. The relationship between projective identification and aggression is explored through case material in which the psychotherapist felt strongly influenced by the patients projections. My title, understanding projective identification, is intentionally ambiguous. Projective and other disguised tests have a place in psychological marketing research. Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. Pdf projective identification and intersubjectivity researchgate. Projective identification pi is a complex process that can bridge the divide between individual psychodynamics and interpersonal systemic process. Introduction it is a continuing task of psychoanalytic thinking to attempt to generate concepts and consistent.
There it keeps close company with the repetition compulsion that russell. Projective identification and narcissism psychology today. The concept of projective identification was introduced into analytic thinking by melanie klein in 1946. In projective identification however, there is the aim of to control the behaviors of counterpart klein 1952. Projection, introjection, and projective identification. Projective identification pi is a complex process that can bridge the divide. Employers and employees, married and dating couples, and parents and children often bring this matrix of projective identification to their ongoing relationships, much to everyones discomfort. Projective identification may be invoked by men to induce the other partner to carry split off threatening parts of the self. Projective identification is a term introduced by melanie klein and then widely adopted in. Thomass intense yearning for one more dance with his father introjective identification vs. Projective identification is a slightly complex phenomenon that builds on the defense mechanism of projection. Projective identification is a term introduced by melanie klein and then widely adopted in psychoanalytic psychotherapy according to the american psychological association, the expression can have two meanings.
Projective phantasies may or may not be accompanied by evocative behaviour unconsciously intended to induce the recipient of the. Projection, identification, projective identification kindle edition by sandler, joseph, sandler, joseph. These two concepts are highly related in that projective identification involves projection. In fact, the influence is real, but it is not the imagined absolute control by means of transplanted aspects of the self inhabiting the object.
Projective identification and game analysis ken woods, 1996. This site is like a library, use search box in the. Narcissists projection, projective identification and. In this paper i aim both to show how the psychoanalyst comes to understand what the patient is trying to communicate in projective identification, and to enable the lay person to understand what projective identification is. Dealing with projective identification in couple therapy. Projective identification is an unconsc i ous phantasy in which aspects of the self or an internal object are split off and attributed to an external object the projected aspects may be felt by the projector to be either good or bad. The view that projective identification is one of the cruel weaponsalbeit an unconscious weaponin the toolbox of a narcissist is a creative and intriguing notion.
Once what is meant by projective identification has been clarified, a brief historical overview of the concept is offered. The nature of the difference between projection as an independent process and projection as a part of projective identification will be discussed later in this paper. In this book elizabeth spillius and edna oshaughnessy explore the development of the concept of projective identification, which had important antecedents in the work of freud and others, but. This book is a clear, constructive, and instructive treatment of an important observation.
The term originated of course from the work of melanie klein in her ground breaking work on the paranoidschizoid and depressive phases of childhood development in the 1940s and has since been much researched and expanded upon. I hope to simplify the murky concept of projective identification so it is readily useable for therapists. Article information, pdf download for projective identification in. Projective identification and maternal failure mrs klein, wrote mrs spillius, thought of projective identification as a phantasy in which bad parts of the self were split off from the rest of the self and, together with bad excrements, were projected into the mother or her breast to control or take. The way in which the concepts of splitting and projective identification have evolved in melanie klein s work illustrates very well, i think, the creative interaction between theory and clinical observation, which runs through psychoanalysis.
The concept of projective identification that the object is being controlled by the projector. Conversely, analysis of projective identification reveals the unconscious defensive function of a game. Projective identification from this point of view is actually a more primitive mechanism than projection. Projective identification is the unconscious projection of unwanted aspects of ones self into others, leading to the bolstering of a conscious selfview concordant. Article information, pdf download for projection and projective identification. Psychology definition of projective identification 1. Projective identification david and jill scharff state that, in current usage, british object relations theorists have defined projective identification as the process through which a person projects a disclaimed part of the self into the other, and the other person unconsciously takes it in and feels like that projected part through. Finally, on the basis of the understand ing of projective identification arrived at earlier in the paper, there is a discussion of the resulting implications for psychotherapeutic technique. Certain aspects of the phenomena considered under the concept of projective identification, notably those concerned with the relationship between intrapsychic and interpersonal phenomena and with indirect forms of communication and influence, are discussed. Through a variety of interpersonal and intrapsychic dynamics, the patient. This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book.
Projective identification in sexual abuse survivors and. Projective identification as a contributor to domestic violence. A clinical exploration of the concept from a contemporary freudian perspective. Projective identification is a complex and much misunderstood concept in the world of psychotherapy. Projective identification makes sense of so much that we find ourselves feeling when were with children and young people. Projective identification is for klein 1946 a crucial mechanism of defence. The range of viewpoint is expectedly wide, but always informative. Projective identification is a psychological term first introduced by the british psychoanalist melanie klein, to describe the psychological process by which a person projects a thought or belief that they have onto a second person. The fate of a concept will appeal to any psychoanalyst or psychotherapist who uses the ideas of transference and countertransference, as well as to academics wanting further insight into the evolution of this concept as it moves between different cultures and countries. That sneaky devil, projective identification psychology. The study of scale development, reliability and validity. Projective identification and psychotherapeutic technique. Finally, on the basis of the understanding of projective identification arrived at earlier in the paper, there is a discussion of the resulting implications for psychotherapeutic technique and.
A defense mechanism as described in psychoanalysis. What is the difference between projection and projective. One common coupling that contains this dynamic is the pairing of the constantly frustrated critic with the seemingly incompetent, bumbling partner. Ogden explains the patients identification in treatment with a significant other for purposes of mastering traumatic experiences.
Towards the logic of projective identification sciencedirect. The narcissists solipsistic worldview prevents him from successfully getting rid of what bothers him the most. Projective identification or relational introjection. Projective identification is a clinical enactment and part of the common currency of the psychoanalytic process that occurs especially around difficult nodal points at the deepest levels of our psychic organization. Motivation is the activation or energization of goaloriented behavior. Projective techniques pt clinical psychology consumer, marketing, advertising research generally known as motivation research cf. Reflections on countertransference and the ends of. Projection, identification, projective identification. In this psychologenie post, we will provide a simple explanation of this theory along with some examples. With the narcissist, projection and projective identification dont work because, in his mental world, there are no others, no outside, and no reality. Understanding projective identification in psychotherapy. A recording of a klein studies evening organised by the melanie klein trust at which panel members john steiner, elizabeth spillius, edna oshaughnessy and ignes sodre discussed the concept of projective identification with contributions from the audience. Click download or read online button to get intersubjectivity projective identification and otherness book now.
275 762 246 1050 555 1226 1097 589 364 1170 1661 353 1618 144 958 1014 1197 108 1111 1026 321 400 163 68 1217 14 700 88 947 225 671 1187 1433 569 1002 317 1162